CO129-541-5 Harbour Light dues- proposed amendments 11-8-1932 - 22-5-1933 — Page 39

3.

- 2 -

The comparison with Manila is scarcely apposite as the authorities there have undertaken large harbour schemes and wharf development.

39 END

The system of compound fees admittedly penalises the occasional callers, but it is submitted that the regular trader deserves more consideration than the occasional caller. It is the regular companies who, whether cargo is plentiful or scarce, maintain regular services from the Port and provide the backbone of the Colony's revenue by the trade which they render possible.

It is accepted by the Government of China and Japan and by other Governments that a system of compounded fees is equitable and we see no reason why the Hong Kong Government should accept the view that the interests of occasional callers should be given prior consideration to those of the regular companies.

My Committee earnestly expresses the hope that on recon- sideration the Government will agree to (a) a reduction in Light Dues, or (b) the introduction of a system of compounded fees.

I have the honour to be,

Sir,

Your obedient Servant,

(Sgd) M.F.Key,

Secretary.